Kishanganga Dam Issue

Kishanganga Issues : Overview and Significance

The Kishanganga Dam issue is a significant point of contention between India and Pakistan, primarily concerning water rights and regional geopolitics. The dam, constructed on the Kishanganga River (known as the Neelum River in Pakistan), has been a focal point in the broader dispute over water resources in the Indus Basin.

Background

The Kishanganga Dam is located in the Indian-administered region of Jammu and Kashmir. It is a hydroelectric project intended to harness the river’s flow to generate power, particularly to benefit the power-starved regions of northern India. The project was initiated by India as part of its strategy to develop its hydroelectric potential in the region.

Dispute Origins

The controversy primarily arises from the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT), signed in 1960 between India and Pakistan, which regulates water distribution from the Indus River and its tributaries. According to the treaty:

  • The Eastern Rivers (the Ravi, Beas, and Chenab) are allocated to India.
  • The Western Rivers (the Indus, Jhelum, and Chenab) are allocated to Pakistan.

 

The Kishanganga River is a tributary of the Jhelum River, and according to the IWT, India has the right to use the waters of the Western Rivers for agricultural and domestic purposes, provided that it does not adversely affect Pakistan’s water rights.

Key Issues

  1. Water Flow Reduction: Pakistan argues that the construction of the Kishanganga Dam will significantly reduce the flow of water into the Neelum River, affecting its water availability for agriculture and power generation in Pakistan. The reduction in flow could potentially impact the lower riparian rights of Pakistan as per the IWT.

  2. Design and Operation: India’s dam design involves diverting part of the river’s flow through a tunnel to a power station, which Pakistan claims violates the IWT by diverting water away from the Neelum River and impacting downstream water availability.

  3. Legal and Diplomatic Actions: The issue was brought before the International Court of Arbitration (ICA) under the IWT’s dispute resolution mechanism. In 2013, the ICA ruled that India must reduce the height of the Kishanganga Dam’s spillways to ensure that the flow to Pakistan is not adversely affected. However, the ruling allowed India to continue with its project while adhering to the court’s guidelines.

Implications and Developments

  1. Regional Tensions: The Kishanganga Dam issue has exacerbated tensions between India and Pakistan, contributing to broader geopolitical friction in the region. Both countries have used water disputes as leverage in their diplomatic relations.

  2. Impact on Local Communities: The construction and operation of the dam have affected local communities in the Indian-administered areas, leading to displacement and socio-economic changes. It also has implications for the local ecology and environment.

  3. Strategic Considerations: For India, the Kishanganga Dam is part of a larger strategy to enhance its hydroelectric capacity and manage water resources more effectively. For Pakistan, the issue is critical for ensuring that its water rights under the IWT are upheld and for maintaining agricultural productivity.

Conclusion

The Kishanganga Dam issue exemplifies the complex interplay between international treaties, national interests, and regional geopolitics. It underscores the challenges of managing shared water resources in a manner that respects international agreements while addressing national development needs. For UPSC aspirants, understanding this issue provides insight into international water disputes, diplomatic negotiations, and the broader context of Indo-Pak relations.

FAQ's - Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Kishanganga Dam issue?

The Kishanganga Dam issue refers to the conflict between India and Pakistan over the construction and operation of the Kishanganga Dam, also known as the Neelum-Jhelum Project, on the Kishanganga River in the Gurez Valley of Jammu and Kashmir. This river is a tributary of the Jhelum River, which flows into Pakistan.

The controversy arises from concerns over the dam’s impact on water flow into Pakistan. Pakistan argues that the dam’s construction violates the Indus Waters Treaty of 1960, which governs water-sharing arrangements between the two countries. India, on the other hand, maintains that the dam is in compliance with the treaty’s provisions.

The Indus Waters Treaty is a water-sharing agreement signed between India and Pakistan in 1960. It allocates the use of the Indus River system’s waters between the two countries. The treaty gives India control over the waters of the eastern rivers (Ravi, Beas, and Chenab) and Pakistan control over the western rivers (Jhelum, Chenab, and Indus).

Pakistan’s primary concerns include:

  • Reduction in Water Flow: Pakistan fears that the dam will significantly reduce the flow of water into the Neelum River, which is crucial for its agriculture and hydropower projects.
  • Violation of Treaty Provisions: Pakistan alleges that India’s actions contravene the Indus Waters Treaty’s terms regarding the diversion and storage of river waters.

India argues that:

  • Compliance with IWT: The Kishanganga Dam complies with the Indus Waters Treaty, as the treaty allows India to construct storage works on the western rivers for purposes such as power generation and flood control, provided that these do not adversely impact Pakistan’s water rights.
  • Design Features: India has designed the dam to ensure that it does not affect the downstream flow significantly, adhering to treaty provisions concerning water flow and storage.
  • Diplomatic Engagement: India and Pakistan have engaged in diplomatic discussions to address concerns and find a mutually acceptable solution.
  • International Mediation: Pakistan sought arbitration from the International Court of Arbitration (ICA), which issued a ruling in 2013. The ICA’s decision allowed India to proceed with the dam but with certain conditions to mitigate adverse effects on Pakistan’s water flow.

The ICA’s ruling in 2013 allowed India to continue with the construction of the Kishanganga Dam but required India to adhere to certain conditions to ensure minimal impact on Pakistan’s water rights. This included maintaining a certain minimum flow of water during periods of low flow.

  • Economic Impact: The dam could impact agriculture and livelihoods dependent on the river in the Gurez Valley and downstream regions in Pakistan.
  • Environmental Impact: There may be ecological consequences, such as changes in river flow patterns and effects on local biodiversity.

The issue is part of the larger framework of India-Pakistan relations and reflects the complexities of transboundary water management. It influences bilateral negotiations, regional stability, and cooperation on water resources.

  • Understand the Background: Familiarize yourself with the Indus Waters Treaty and the history of India-Pakistan water disputes.
  • Review Recent Developments: Stay updated on recent rulings, negotiations, and political developments related to the Kishanganga Dam.
  • Analyze Impacts: Consider the economic, environmental, and geopolitical impacts of the dam issue.
  • Practice Writing: Develop the ability to articulate the issue clearly and provide balanced analysis in your answers.

Maximize the benefits of mock tests for IAS and KAS preparation with guidance from Amoghavarsha IAS Academy . For more details, visit https://amoghavarshaiaskas.in/.

Youtube: click here

Enroll Now !
Media & News