- Amoghavarsha IAS Broucher
- +91 9916766911 / 8088776736
- info@amoghavarshaiaskas.in
- E-Learning
- Blog
Constitutional Basis
The 14th Amendment, ratified in 1868, states:
“All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.”
This clause, historically designed to grant citizenship to former slaves, has been interpreted broadly to include virtually all individuals born on U.S. soil.
Jus Soli vs. Jus Sanguinis
Jus Soli (Right of the Soil): Citizenship is granted based on birth location.
Jus Sanguinis (Right of Blood): Citizenship is granted based on the nationality of parents.
The U.S. follows jus soli, while many other countries, including India, primarily follow jus sanguinis with some modifications.
The Executive Order’s Objectives
Trump argued that birthright citizenship incentivized illegal immigration and “birth tourism,” wherein foreign nationals enter the U.S. to give birth, ensuring automatic citizenship for their child. The executive order aimed to redefine the 14th Amendment’s jurisdiction clause to exclude children born to non-citizens and unauthorized immigrants.
Trump’s administration contended that:
The term “subject to the jurisdiction” does not extend to individuals without legal status.
The existing interpretation of the 14th Amendment had been overly expansive and was not consistent with its original intent.
Judicial Precedents
The Role of the Judiciary
Given the constitutional implications, any such executive order would likely face immediate legal challenges. The ultimate decision would rest with the Supreme Court, raising questions about judicial interpretation of originalism vs. living constitutionalism.
For the U.S.
Demographic Shifts: Limiting birthright citizenship could lead to a rise in stateless individuals and create barriers to integration for children born to non-citizens.
Immigration Policy: It could deter illegal immigration but might also lead to complex legal battles and enforcement issues.
Economic Impact: Restricting citizenship could affect industries reliant on immigrant labor and alter population growth trends.
For International Norms
The U.S. would align with countries that have restricted birthright citizenship, such as Germany and Japan. However, it could face criticism for deviating from inclusive democratic principles.
Birthright Citizenship in India
India initially followed a jus soli approach but amended its laws to incorporate stricter jus sanguinis principles:
Lessons for India
Trump’s executive order highlights debates over immigration and citizenship that resonate with India’s own challenges, such as the implementation of the NRC (National Register of Citizens) and the CAA (Citizenship Amendment Act).
Sovereignty vs. Universal Rights
Ending birthright citizenship raises questions about the balance between national sovereignty and adherence to universal human rights principles.
Statelessness Concerns
Restricting citizenship by birth could exacerbate the global issue of statelessness, leaving individuals without nationality or legal protections.
Topics to Focus On
Essay and Mains Questions
Trump’s executive order to end birthright citizenship underscores a significant ideological and constitutional debate in the U.S. It reflects broader global trends where nations grapple with issues of identity, sovereignty, and inclusion.
For UPSC aspirants, understanding such developments provides insights into the interplay between law, policy, and governance. It emphasizes the importance of constitutional safeguards, judicial interpretation, and ethical considerations in shaping inclusive societies.
In a world of increasing mobility and migration, the debate over birthright citizenship serves as a reminder of the complexities surrounding national identity and the universal rights of individuals.
Maximize the benefits of mock tests for IAS and KAS preparation with guidance from Amoghavarsha IAS Academy . For more details, visit https://amoghavarshaiaskas.in/.
Youtube: click here
Amoghavarsha IAS/KAS Academy was founded in 2014 since from their we have been excellence in the field of civil Service examination preparation and state services. The Academy is completely dedicated to provide excellent quality education by experts and bringing innovations etc.
Copyright © 2014 – 2024 Amoghavarsha IAS Academy. All Rights Reserved
Developed & Maintained by BIGGSITE
Amoghavarsha E Magazine
Current Affairs ( Prelims )
UPSC
KPSC
